Report on Final Cut Feedback (Focus Group)
Report
The overall reaction to my final cut was positive, It was clear that the improvements I had made had been received well by my audience. Here are the questions i asked with some of the responses.
1. It was suggested in feedback that I remove the shots of the two characters running, did the replacement of these shots make the music video look more professional?
Answers:
"Yes"
"I didn't mind the running shots but replacement still works"
"Yes improved the pace"
"Yes, made the overall aesthetic of the video more professional"
"Yes the video did look more professional-less cheesy"
"Yeah, I think it also made the video look more stable"
"Yes made the video more interesting to watch, it was less corny"
"Yes, helped with the flow of the video"
Overall, the replacement of these shots received positive reviews from classmates, When I watched my rough cut back I do feel that it was very corny, perhaps if the shots of the running looked more professional this wouldn't have been a problem. I feel changing them did make the video look better overall, there was less repetition.
2. It was also stated in feedback that the narrative was made clearer, did the new rearrangement and addition of new shots make the narrative clearer to you?
Answers:
"No the song was the narrative for me"
"Yes, the beginning made the narrative much clearer"
"Stayed the same"
"Yes, although I found the narrative clear in your rough cut"
"The clarity of your narrative was much better, especially with the addition of the OTS shots of both characters at the beginning"
"Yes"
"Yes"
"Yeah, narrative was much clearer"
The narrative of my music video was a big problem in my rough cut, people didn't really understand what the music video was about, however I worked on this criticism and I feel it paid off as the story telling in my final cut has much more clarity, as seen through the responses.
3. Following Q3, What do you think the story/intention behind the music video was?
Answers:
"One character has died, and the other is grieving their death"
""Two lovers but one died"
"One lover died, the other is trying to 'find' him, perhaps in memories"
"A love story"
"One character died either by a train or at a train station and the other character was remembering their death"
"Makes sense, two people who have a close connection but not allowed to be together"
"Partner died, remembering him?"
"The finding of a lover"
Again, through these responses I can conclude that my story telling was a success, most of my audience were somewhat correct in the overall story of my music video. However, one used a ?, perhaps they were confused as to what I was trying to convey.
4. With the rearrangement of shots, It was feared I would lose the pace of the music in the video, was this the case?
Answers:
"No, pace was adequate"
"No, pace was adequate"
"No it works, the length of shots haven't changed so pace stayed the same, if not improved"
"No, the pace stayed the same as your rough cut"
"No"
"Didn't see a difference in pace, well done"
"No, the short shot lengths followed conventions"
"Not at all"
"Nope"
After taking the running shots out and some others, I feared that I would lose pace at certain/important points in the music video, particularly during the 'beat drops' of the song. However, judging from my responses it is clear this had no affect at all.
5. Were there any video effects/shots that didn't quite fit the conventions of this music video?
Answers:
"No, they all followed conventions of a normal pop video"
"No"
"All were effective, no anomalies that stuck out"
"No"
"The only shot that didn't quite fit conventions was the very fast circling of the sky/trees, didn't really work for me, personally"
"Maybe the slow-motion, or the roses"
"No, not at all"
"Not that I noticed"
Overall, the audience perception of following conventions was positive. However, the person who said "Maybe the slow motion" I would have to argue against, after analysing a pop music video and watching influential videos, slow motion was extremely prominent throughout them which contradicts what they are responding.
6. In your opinion, do you think the video was saturated with certain shot/types?
Answers:
"No not really, there was a nice variety"
"No"
"No- however one shot subject may have been inappropriate but variety was good"
"No, you incorporated a large range of shot type which was enjoyable"
"No, each shot was different"
"A little too much use of ECU shots for my taste"
"Not really, no"
"No"
Some responses I was confused with, especially the inappropriate one. When looking back at my video there is a shot of a character grabbing the bed- the intended emotion was anger however this particular audience member took it the wrong way, perhaps the anger wasn't clear enough in the shots In their defense the shot could be easily misconstrued. Furthermore, I feel I needed the ECU to create a personal atmosphere. However, overall my responses are mostly positive with little to say in terms of improvement.
7.Were the average length of shots fitting for this type of music video?
Answers:
"Yes, they were short and fast, keeping pace withheld throughout the music video"
"Yes"
"I feel that they were too quick during the verses, so the drop during the chorus was less obvious as you couldn't make the shots any shorter"
"Yes, I felt they were just right. Not too short or too long"
"Yes, none of the shots were too long"
"Yes"
"Yes the short shots fitted the pace of music"
"Yes, helped keep up pace in video"
Judging from my response, It is clear that the shot lengths were fitting for this type of music video. As for the comment criticising the chorus, this is perhaps something I could improve on.
8.Do you think the music video would have benefited from a wider variety of shot types?
Answers:
"No, there was enough to fulfill my engagement"
"Possibly, something for the last beat drop"
"Not really"
"No"
"The video could have benefited from some mid shots but is fine at the moment"
"No it's fine on it's own"
"Not really I could suggest to add that would fit this style of video"
"It could have, but it wouldn't be necessary as it's fine as it is"
There were mixed responses to this question, however it has mostly positive responses. I do think myself that perhaps there could've been more of a variety, particularly when identifying the two characters so the audience could see more of them.
9.Overall, how would you score this music video on a scale of 1-10?
Answers:
"7.5"
"8"
"7"
"9"
"7"
"8.5"
"9"
"7"
I am extremely happy with the overall rating of my music video from each of my audience member.No one scored the video below 5. I am also happy with my final product, I feel i followed conventions of similar products which is evident in the responses I have been given. However, there were a few things I could have improved on, that was adding some more shot types, diversifying my range. And perhaps removing the shot that the audience member described as "inappropriate" out of the video as I don't want to offend anyone. These are the only corrections I feel i'd need to make to cater it to my target audience.
Answers:
"7.5"
"8"
"7"
"9"
"7"
"8.5"
"9"
"7"
I am extremely happy with the overall rating of my music video from each of my audience member.No one scored the video below 5. I am also happy with my final product, I feel i followed conventions of similar products which is evident in the responses I have been given. However, there were a few things I could have improved on, that was adding some more shot types, diversifying my range. And perhaps removing the shot that the audience member described as "inappropriate" out of the video as I don't want to offend anyone. These are the only corrections I feel i'd need to make to cater it to my target audience.
1 to 1 feedback from teacher:
Comments
Post a Comment